These are well-known facts, although Sunni scholars keep them hidden from their
followers.'
Allamah Qawshaji and 'Allamah Taftazani (two authoritative Sunni scholars and
theologians) have written in their books, Sharh Tajrid and Sharh Maqasid, respectively,
that:
“Umar (2nd Caliph) said: 'There were three things in the days of the Messenger of Allah (S.A.W). I forbid them and make them haram (unlawful) and shall punish for them: Mut'ah (marriage) of women and Hajjut-Tamattu', and Hayya 'ala Khayril-amal.”
Imam Malik ibn Anas has narrated in his al-Muwatta' that during the caliphate of 'Umar the
Mu'azzin came to call him for the dawn prayer and found him asleep.
He said: As-salatu Khayrum minan nawm (Prayer is better than sleep);
'Umar woke up and ordered the Mu'azzin to include it in the Adhan of Fajr." (Kanzul ummal, vol. 4, p. 270).
When 'Ali (A.S) heard it, he said: "Do not add in Adhan what is not in it." (Naylul-Awtar of Imam Shaukani, vol. 1, p. 238).
But obviously, Khalifa's order was obeyed.
Many other references can be quoted for these things, if necessary.
followers.'
Allamah Qawshaji and 'Allamah Taftazani (two authoritative Sunni scholars and
theologians) have written in their books, Sharh Tajrid and Sharh Maqasid, respectively,
that:
“Umar (2nd Caliph) said: 'There were three things in the days of the Messenger of Allah (S.A.W). I forbid them and make them haram (unlawful) and shall punish for them: Mut'ah (marriage) of women and Hajjut-Tamattu', and Hayya 'ala Khayril-amal.”
Imam Malik ibn Anas has narrated in his al-Muwatta' that during the caliphate of 'Umar the
Mu'azzin came to call him for the dawn prayer and found him asleep.
He said: As-salatu Khayrum minan nawm (Prayer is better than sleep);
'Umar woke up and ordered the Mu'azzin to include it in the Adhan of Fajr." (Kanzul ummal, vol. 4, p. 270).
When 'Ali (A.S) heard it, he said: "Do not add in Adhan what is not in it." (Naylul-Awtar of Imam Shaukani, vol. 1, p. 238).
But obviously, Khalifa's order was obeyed.
Many other references can be quoted for these things, if necessary.
LoL seriously.. what a bunch of fabrications. If Sayydna Ali indeed would have said that, than why do Shia include "ashadu anna Ali waliyyullah" in their Athan! Also, you don't say AS after mentioning Sayydna Ali's name. This is reserved for Prophets and Messengers only!
ReplyDeleteAshadu anna Ali an waliyyullah is proven from Quran when Allah says ...Obey Allah....We say LA ILAHA ILLALAH
ReplyDelete...Obey Rasool...We say..MOHAMADUR RASULLALLAH
...obey Ulul Amr...We say ALIYUN WALIYULLAH
Shia Kalma is proved from Quran
Secondly if AS is only for Nabi then Why AS is used for IMAM MAHDI in sunni books ???