(Al-Melal wa al-Nehal -Abu al-Fath Muhammad Ibn Abd al-Karim Ibn Abi Bakr Ahmed Shahrastaani (exp. 548 A.H.) )
ORIGINAL SCANNED ARABIC PAGE OF THE BOOK "KITAB Al-Melal wa al-Nehal" PAGE 51 |
ENGLISH TRANSALATION :
"VERILY UMAR STUCK SO HARD AT HAZRAT FATIMA ZAHRA (SA) IN HER STOMACH ON THE DAY OF ALLEGIANCE THAT SHE SUFFERED THE MISCARRIAGE OF JANABE MOHSIN . AND UMAR WAS SHOUTING TO BURN THE HOUSE OF JANABE FATIMAH ALONG WITH THE PEOPLE INSIDE IT, ALTHOUGH AT THAT TIME THERE WERE NONE OTHER THAN HAZRAT ALI , HAZRAT FATIMA , HASAN AND HUSSAIN (AMS) IN THE HOUSE ".
Mr Shahrani had become an Ismaili... this has been the view of Ulama e Ahl us Sunnah e.g Dhahabi etc. Earlier they had thought that once a sunni he had become Athna Ashari but his work/doctrines was making it clear that he was an Ismaili. So to present him as a representative of Sunnis is a mistake.
ReplyDeleteLanat ho Dushumane Ahlebeit pe
ReplyDelete