brother nawaf made an interesting observation
let me share that with you
he mentioned this narration from sunan ibn maja
1963 حدثنا محمد بن خلف العسقلاني حدثنا الفريابي عن أبان بن أبي حازم عن أبي بكر بن حفص عن ابن عمر قال لما ولي عمر بن الخطاب خطب الناس فقال إن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم أذن لنا في المتعة ثلاثا ثم حرمها والله لا أعلم أحدا يتمتع وهو محصن إلا رجمته بالحجارة إلا أن يأتيني بأربعة يشهدون أن رسول الله أحلها بعد إذ حرمها
ibn umar said that when umar became WALI (urdu translation says when he became caliph), he delivered a speech, so he said: holy prophet asws gave us permission to do muta’a three times, and then he prohibited it. by god! if i come to know that any of you did muta’a and he is married, i ll punish him with stones (rajam) except that he brings me 4 people (of course they have to be sahaba) who testify that holy prophet asws allowed it after he prohibited it
as regards to authenticity, let me add that
1- albany included this in his sahih ibn maja, vol 2, page 154, narration 1611: he terms it HASAN
2- hafiz abu tahir zubair ali zai terms in HASAN in urdu translation of sunan ibn maja, vol 3, narration 1963
3- sheikh maqbal al widai included it in his الصحيح المسند مما ليس في الصحيحين , and termed it HASAN
his observation is that if only one sahabi narrates a narration, wont that be a hujjat?
if yes, why was omer asking for 4?
and my addition to this is that here the word used for caliph/khalifa is WALI
here is the link to article of brother nawaf
http://www.alkafi.net/vb/showthread.php?t=2121
http://ahlubait.wordpress.com/2012/02/14/authenticity-of-a-narration-if-only-one-sahaba-narrates/
let me share that with you
he mentioned this narration from sunan ibn maja
1963 حدثنا محمد بن خلف العسقلاني حدثنا الفريابي عن أبان بن أبي حازم عن أبي بكر بن حفص عن ابن عمر قال لما ولي عمر بن الخطاب خطب الناس فقال إن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم أذن لنا في المتعة ثلاثا ثم حرمها والله لا أعلم أحدا يتمتع وهو محصن إلا رجمته بالحجارة إلا أن يأتيني بأربعة يشهدون أن رسول الله أحلها بعد إذ حرمها
ibn umar said that when umar became WALI (urdu translation says when he became caliph), he delivered a speech, so he said: holy prophet asws gave us permission to do muta’a three times, and then he prohibited it. by god! if i come to know that any of you did muta’a and he is married, i ll punish him with stones (rajam) except that he brings me 4 people (of course they have to be sahaba) who testify that holy prophet asws allowed it after he prohibited it
as regards to authenticity, let me add that
1- albany included this in his sahih ibn maja, vol 2, page 154, narration 1611: he terms it HASAN
2- hafiz abu tahir zubair ali zai terms in HASAN in urdu translation of sunan ibn maja, vol 3, narration 1963
3- sheikh maqbal al widai included it in his الصحيح المسند مما ليس في الصحيحين , and termed it HASAN
his observation is that if only one sahabi narrates a narration, wont that be a hujjat?
if yes, why was omer asking for 4?
and my addition to this is that here the word used for caliph/khalifa is WALI
here is the link to article of brother nawaf
http://www.alkafi.net/vb/showthread.php?t=2121
http://ahlubait.wordpress.com/2012/02/14/authenticity-of-a-narration-if-only-one-sahaba-narrates/
Categories:
Arabic - العربية
,
English
0 comments:
Post a Comment
براہ مہربانی شائستہ زبان کا استعمال کریں۔ تقریبا ہر موضوع پر 'گمنام' لوگوں کے بہت سے تبصرے موجود ہیں. اس لئےتاریخ 20-3-2015 سے ہم گمنام کمینٹنگ کو بند کر رہے ہیں. اس تاریخ سے درست ای میل اکاؤنٹس کے ضریعے آپ تبصرہ کر سکتے ہیں.جن تبصروں میں لنکس ہونگے انہیں فوراً ہٹا دیا جائے گا. اس لئے آپنے تبصروں میں لنکس شامل نہ کریں.
Please use Polite Language.
As there are many comments from 'anonymous' people on every subject. So from 20-3-2015 we are disabling 'Anonymous Commenting' option. From this date only users with valid E-mail accounts can comment. All the comments with LINKs will be removed. So please don't add links to your comments.