The Shias of Umar ibn Khattab attributing lies to the Shias of Ali (a.s.)

One of my friend sent this to me :

(i) Aytollah  Khomaini stated in his book "Tahir-u-Wasila, Vol 2, Page 292" that (Mu'ta) can be done for one day, one night, and even for a few hours.  He further states on the same page that "Mu'ta is allowed with a (known) adulterous woman and Mu'ta with a  prostitute is undesirable (but not Haram)". (Astaghfirullah).

(ii) On page 356 in volume 1 (Para 5) of 'Tafseer Minhaj us Sadiqeen' (widely read and referred by Shias) it is mentioned that Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه و آله وسلم) said : "One who does Mu'ta once in his life will attain the rank of Imam Husain (رضئ اللہ تعالی عنہ); one who does it twice, will attain the rank of Imam Hasan (رضئ اللہ تعالی عنہ); one who does it thrice will attain the rank of Ameeral Mo'mineen Hadhrat Ali (رضئ اللہ تعالی عنہ) and one who does it four times will attain my ( ie Prophet - (صلى الله عليه و آله وسلم) rank."  (Astaghfirullah, Ma'azallah).  Such a great lie is attributed to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه و آله وسلم).

Is this is the lowest Shias can get?

No it is more than that.  The same Tafseer, Volume 1 it is written that "the number of women that a person can be engaged in Mu'ta at a (one) time is unlimited". Meaning, a Shia can engage several women in an orgy at a time.  The more he does, the more higher spiritual rank he will attain.  (La haula wala quwwata illah billah).

(iii) Recently a Fatwa was issued by a famous Shia Scholar. A Questioner asked the Scholar "I know a virgin Sunni girl. Is it permissible to perform Mu'ta (read sexual inter course) with her without permission of her Wali (Guardian/Father)? Or have (intimate) talk (with her) without sex?

The Scholar replied : It is permissible (to do Mu'ta) without permission of the Wali, with or without penetration (sexual Inter Course).  Imam Rohani's Official Website - http://www.imamrohani.com

So I thought, lets check if this things exists in the books or not.

I did a simple registration on NOOR DIGITAL LIBRARY where I found this book (Tafseer Minhaj us Sadiqeen) :

http://www.noorlib.ir/View/fa/Book/BookView/Image/12083

I moved to Volume 1 Page 356

This  is what I found :

Click to enlarge

I searched in Arabic if this really exists and I came across this link :

http://shiaweb.org/books/llah_llhaq/pa28.html

Where I found this :

قال الكاتب: وروى السيد فتح الله الكاشاني في تفسير منهج الصادقين عن النبي (ص) أنه قال: (مَن تمتَّع مرة كانت كدرجة الحسين رضي الله عنه، ومن تمتع مرتين فدرجته كدرجة الحسن رضي الله عنه ، ومَن تمتع ثلاث مرات كانت درجته كدرجة علي بن أبي طالب رضي الله عنه، ومَن تمتع أربع فدرجته كدرجتي).

وأقول: هذا الحديث غير موجود في كتب الشيعة، ولهذا لم يذكر له الكاتب رقم المجلد والصفحة فراراً من الفضيحة.

Then I decided to check the Website of Mr. Rohani who according to the SHIAs OF UMAR permits muta with Sunni and other Muslim women without the permission of their WALI (Guardian).

I checked it and found this :

Click to enlarge

Mr. Rohani says that it is permissible with Ahle Kitab Women without the permission of her WALI. This is not regarding Muslim Women of any sect.

About Mr. Khomeini I am not sure. I have not checked this. But most probably it is also fake and lie. If it was true my Sunni / Wahabi brothers would have produced SCAN proof of the same. But they have not.

Like everytime, the SHIAs of UMAR are found to be lying and misquoting.

The Sunnis never ever presented a Single Scan of any Shia Book as a reference. I challenge the followers of Umar to present the SCAN of the page where it says Muta elevates the rank of the doer to the rank of Imam Husain (a.s.) and such things. Naudhubillah.

This Ignorant without checking the sources accuses the Shias of such things that are not found in their books. These are called as Sunni SCHOLARS !!!!

زناي رسمي!!!

دين تشيع دين فساد و بي بندو باريست. ديني که زنا را با لباس و ظاهر اسلامي اراسته مي کند و به مردم مي دهد.

و آنچنان غلو درباره اش کرده اند که بعضي از رواياتشان مي گويد که كسيكه در طول زندگي خويش يكبار صيغه كرده باشد، به مقام و منزلت حسين -عليه السلام- و كسيكه سه بار صيغه كرده باشد به مقام و منزلت علي بن ابي طالب -عليه السلام- خواهد رسيد. و كسيكه چهار بار متعه كند به مقام و منزلت من(محمد) نائل خواهد آمد. تفسير منهج الصادقين للملا الكاشاني 2/493

به دروغ از امام صادق روايت کرده اند که گفته است: هر کس به رجعت و صيغه ايمان نداشته باشد از ما نيست. الصافي للكاشاني 1/347 ، من لا يحضره الفقيه 3/458

و همچنين روايت مي کنند که امام صادق گفته: منكر متعه مرتد و كافر و قبول كننده آن مؤمن و موحد است. متعه دو اجر دارد. اجر صدقه اي كه به زن داده مي شود و اجر خود متعه
تفسير منهج الصادقين للملا الكاشاني 2/495

خواننده ي محترم ديديد که متعه نزد انانواجب مي باشد و منکر ان کافر؟

Categories: English , Persian - فارسی