Innovations(Bid'ah) of Umar in Islam!

 All Muslims should read this post seriously and decide whether Umar should be given due respect after all these Innovations and sins in Islam.He(Umar) was responsible for bringing about so many changes in Islam. When Holy Prophet(s.a.w) had not done certain things then who has authorized him to get all these changes in Islam. 1. Bidah of banning muta al nisa and hajj 2. Bidah of tathweeb in adhaan 3. Bidah of declaring triple pronouncement of talaq in one sitting as final talaq 4. Bidah of congregational tarawih prayer 5. Speaking against Tayamum and being unaware of its laws 6. Being away from mosque in time of prayers in the life of Prophet Mohammad (s) and engaging in worldly things. 7. Bidah of racism and tribalism in the name of Kufu and Quraishi Nobility...

UMAR BIN AL KHATTAB: Worthy Of Prophethood?-Part IV

Now let us expose Suyyuti’s shocking and self-contradicting statements which he tried to disguise as truths in his book so that the reader will have the conclusive proof that our commentary on Suyyuti is not based on harboring any ill feelings towards him or his supporters: As for his (Suyyuti’s) statement, “Verily Ibn Hibban talked of Zakariyyah in his book "Al Thiqaat" (*)”: Then yes that is accepted but then he (Ibn Hibban) is from those who dont consider him worthy of being authentic because the criticisms against Zakariyyah are many from the greatest of the Sunni Ulama. Ibn Adi said: Verily He (Zakariyyah) fabricated hadith Saalih Jazrah said: Verily He (Zakariyyah) is from the Liars Ibn Younus also declared the same and called him Daeef even after complimenting him! (*)...

UMAR BIN AL KHATTAB: Worthy Of Prophethood?-Part III

The Prophet (s) said to Imam Ali a.s: You are to me on the same rank as Haroon a.s was to Musa a.s except that there would be no prophet after me)  أنت منّي بمنزلة هارون من موسى إلاّ أنّه لا نبيّ بعدي This Hadith has been recorded by the Eminent Sunni Scholar Hafiz Sulaiman al Qundoozi al Hanafi in his Yanabi al Mawadah, through 15 different chains of narrations / paths. And this Hadith is from the path of the Ahlul Sunnah and attested to be accurate by a majority of their muhadiths/scholars. It is in the Sharh (exegesis) of this Sahih Hadith in honor of Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib a.s that Mullah Ali Qari al Hanafi wrote in his "Mirqaat Sharh al Mishqaat" that: فيه إيماء الى أنه لو كان بعده نبيّاً لكان عليّاً "In this hadith is the gesture towards that if there was to...

UMAR BIN AL KHATTAB: Worthy Of Prophethood?-Part II

 The (weak) tradition under discussion is : “The Prophet of Allah (s) said about Umar bin al Khattaab: If there had been after me, a Nabi (Prophet), it would have been him (i.e Umar)” .......continued from Part I  5- Umar was terribly scared and worried about his eeman and he used to ask huzaifa al yamaani many times whether he was from the munafiqeen (ahya uloom al deen az ghazaali). His fear from Azab of Hereafter on his death bed is clear from the fact that he was lamenting on his life record! and wishing if he could give anything in ransom to save himself from this Azaab!!!! The people around him praised him for his virtues and sterling qualities. He asked them not to praise him.  He said:  "All praise is to Allah. If all the treasures of this world...

UMAR BIN AL KHATTAB: Worthy Of Prophethood?-Part I

There is a famous fairy tale with regards to Umar ibn al Khattab amongst a large number of those people who deem themselves to be from Ahl ul Sunnah today: They allege that The Holy Prophet Mohammad (SAW) said: لو كان بعدي نبيّ لكان عمر "If an Apostle/Prophet (Nabi) were to succeed me, it would have been 'Umar bin Khattab." (Tirmidhi) References of this Hadith from Ahl ul Sunnah books are as follows: 1- Musnad Ahmed ibn Hanbal Vol.3 P.163 Hadith No.17336 2- Fadaail al Sahaba...